I think if we'd have the same player across the tournament in 3 and 8, we'd take both. The flowerpot men both have done better than their opposite numbers I reckon. And Dan and Dave have both looked good whilst they played (Dave less so against Ireland of course).
I did wonder about Billy V, almost by excluding everyone else. Wilson hasn't done enough to warrant inclusion in two games, not when for whatever reason he wasn't that good Vs Ireland, so I'd think 3 would have to go to Mike Ross. But left wing? could almost take Medard, it's that or move Huget across and pick Seymour, or pick Halfpenny on the wing - that's possibly being over critical of May and Nowell by naming others who likely weren't much better but I've watched our games back a good few times more than I've seen other teams.